+1(781)975-1541
support-global@metwarebio.com

Unveiling Phosphatidic Acid Ⅱ: Functions, Applications, and Analytical Methods

Phosphatidic acid (PA) is a fascinating and versatile molecule that plays a pivotal role in cell signaling, lipid metabolism, and membrane dynamics. As one of the most fundamental phospholipids, PA serves as a precursor for various important lipids and acts as a key regulator in cellular processes. In the first part of our phosphatidic acid (PA) series, we covered the molecular structure, metabolic pathways, and relationship with other phospholipids. Now, we turn our attention to the remarkable biological functions of PA. This lipid is not only crucial for cell membrane structure and dynamics but also plays a key role in cellular signaling, stress responses, and disease mechanisms.

But PA’s significance extends beyond basic biology—it also holds immense potential in research and industry. From therapeutic applications to bioengineering, PA is a valuable target for a variety of innovative studies. In this second blog of our two-part series, we’ll also explore the latest PA analysis methods and how lipidomics research is uncovering new insights into its functions. If you missed the first part, be sure to check out the link to the earlier blog to get a complete understanding of PA’s role in cellular processes.

  1. What is Phosphatidic Acid?
  2. Structure and Composition of Phosphatidic Acid
  3. The Relationship between Phospholipids and Phosphatidic Acid
  4. Metabolic Pathways of Phosphatidic Acid in Biological Systems
  5. Physiological and Biological Functions of Phosphatidic Acid
  6. Applications of Phosphatidic Acid in Research and Industry
  7. Phosphatidic Acid Analysis Methods
  8. Phosphatidic Acid Lipidomics Research

 

Physiological and Biological Functions of Phosphatidic Acid

Phosphatidic acid (PA) is a crucial molecule in various physiological and biological processes. It not only serves as a precursor for complex lipids but also plays a significant role in cell signaling, membrane dynamics, and cellular stress responses. Below is a detailed exploration of PA’s multifaceted functions.

1. Membrane Biogenesis and Dynamics

PA is a foundational molecule in membrane biogenesis, serving as a precursor for key phospholipids involved in forming cellular membranes. The ability of PA to interact with membrane components is essential for the construction and maintenance of the lipid bilayer. PA's small, negatively charged headgroup induces membrane curvature, which is vital for the formation of new membranes and the restructuring of existing ones. This feature plays a pivotal role during cell division, growth, and the adaptation to environmental changes. In addition to its structural role, PA is involved in the regulation of membrane protein functions, ensuring that membrane dynamics support cellular processes such as signaling and communication between compartments.

Furthermore, PA is essential in maintaining membrane fluidity, particularly in the face of changing environmental conditions. During stress or rapid growth, the composition of phospholipids in the cell membrane can be rapidly adjusted, and PA is key to this adaptability. By modulating the proportion of other phospholipids, PA ensures that the physical properties of the membrane support cellular processes, such as protein folding, lipid trafficking, and the formation of membrane-bound structures.

2. Lipid Signaling Molecule

Phosphatidic acid plays a vital role as a lipid signaling molecule, influencing a variety of cellular pathways. As a second messenger, PA activates several key enzymes and signaling pathways that regulate cell growth, survival, and metabolism. One of the most well-known pathways involves PA’s activation of the mechanistic target of rapamycin (mTOR), a master regulator of cell growth and metabolism. Through this interaction, PA promotes protein synthesis and inhibits autophagy, contributing to cellular proliferation and survival. PA is also involved in regulating various kinases and phosphatases, thus affecting signaling cascades linked to cell cycle progression and apoptosis.

Beyond its action in the mTOR pathway, PA’s role as a signaling molecule extends to processes such as endocytosis, membrane trafficking, and immune responses. PA interacts with a range of proteins, including those with PH domains (pleckstrin homology), which mediate PA-dependent signaling at the membrane. In this way, PA is not only a structural component but a dynamic regulator of various signal transduction pathways, making it central to cellular communication.

Multiple roles of phosphatidic acid (PA) (Zhou et al., 2024)

Multiple roles of phosphatidic acid (PA) (Zhou et al., 2024)

3. Cytoskeletal Regulation

Phosphatidic acid plays a key role in cytoskeletal dynamics, influencing cell shape, motility, and division. The ability of PA to regulate the actin cytoskeleton is particularly critical for cellular processes such as migration, adhesion, and cytokinesis. By interacting with actin-binding proteins, PA can facilitate the polymerization of actin filaments, promoting the formation of filopodia and lamellipodia, structures essential for cell movement. In the context of cell division, PA helps regulate the dynamics of microtubules and actin filaments to ensure proper mitotic progression.

Additionally, PA is involved in controlling the mechanical properties of the cell through its effects on the cytoskeleton. By modulating the balance between actin filaments and other cytoskeletal elements, PA helps cells adapt to changes in shape and mechanical stress. This function is crucial in tissues requiring constant remodeling, such as in developing embryos, wound healing, and immune cell activation.

4. Vesicle Trafficking and Fusion

One of PA’s most critical roles is in vesicle trafficking and membrane fusion, both of which are fundamental for cellular communication and function. PA influences the budding and fusion of vesicles, processes that are central to the movement of cargo between cellular compartments such as the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), Golgi apparatus, and plasma membrane. The curvature-inducing property of PA plays a pivotal role in vesicle formation, especially during endocytosis and exocytosis. Through its interaction with vesicle-associated proteins, PA facilitates the transport of materials within the cell and to the extracellular space.

In addition to vesicle formation, PA regulates vesicle docking and fusion, processes essential for neurotransmitter release, hormone secretion, and the formation of membrane-bound organelles. The ability of PA to interact with specific protein complexes involved in membrane fusion, such as SNARE proteins, underscores its central role in maintaining cellular homeostasis and function. These vesicle trafficking processes are crucial for proper cellular signaling and response to external stimuli.

5. Role in Stress and Adaptation

PA plays a vital role in cellular responses to various forms of stress, including oxidative stress, osmotic stress, and mechanical stress. In conditions where cells face nutrient deprivation or environmental challenges, PA accumulates and participates in stress signaling pathways that help the cell adapt and survive. For example, in response to osmotic stress, PA modulates the activity of key stress-responsive proteins and enzymes, activating protective mechanisms such as chaperone protein expression and antioxidant production. This helps the cell maintain integrity and function under adverse conditions.

In plants, PA is particularly important for responding to drought and salt stress, acting as a signaling molecule to activate protective responses that help the plant maintain water balance and cellular structure. In animals, PA plays a similar role in cellular adaptation to physical stressors, helping cells respond to mechanical forces such as stretch or shear stress. Thus, PA functions as a key player in ensuring cellular resilience in the face of environmental and physiological stress.

6. Impact on Health and Disease

Phosphatidic acid’s involvement in cellular functions extends to human health and disease, with its dysregulation being implicated in various conditions. Elevated levels of PA are linked to several metabolic disorders, including obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. PA contributes to the development of insulin resistance and increased adipogenesis, processes that are central to obesity and metabolic syndrome. Its role in regulating lipid metabolism and inflammation also ties PA to conditions like atherosclerosis and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD), where lipid imbalances and chronic inflammation are key drivers of disease progression.

PA’s role in cancer is particularly significant, as its accumulation has been associated with tumor growth and metastasis. Through its activation of the mTOR pathway and regulation of cellular metabolism, PA promotes cell proliferation and survival, contributing to the aggressive behavior of cancer cells. Moreover, its effects on membrane dynamics and signaling can influence cancer cell motility, invasiveness, and resistance to apoptosis, making it a potential therapeutic target for cancer treatment.

7. Developmental and Evolutionary Significance

Phosphatidic acid has significant developmental and evolutionary implications, playing a key role in cellular differentiation, tissue development, and the evolution of complex life forms. PA's ability to regulate membrane biogenesis and dynamics is crucial during embryogenesis, as cells undergo rapid division and specialization. During development, PA helps guide the formation of various tissues and organs by modulating the composition of cellular membranes and facilitating intercellular signaling.

From an evolutionary perspective, PA’s role in membrane dynamics and cell signaling is thought to have been critical in the emergence of complex life. Its ability to influence lipid metabolism, signaling pathways, and cellular architecture would have been essential for the development of multicellular organisms and the transition from simple to more complex cellular systems. As a fundamental lipid, PA’s presence in a wide variety of organisms highlights its evolutionary significance in maintaining cellular and physiological processes across species.

 

Applications of Phosphatidic Acid in Research and Industry

Phosphatidic acid (PA), owing to its pivotal role in cellular metabolism, membrane dynamics, and lipid signaling, has broad applications across various fields, ranging from basic research to industry. Its versatile functions make it an invaluable tool for studying cellular processes, developing novel therapeutic strategies, and advancing industrial technologies. Below are the key applications of PA in both research and industry.

1. Research Applications in Cellular and Molecular Biology

PA’s central role in membrane dynamics, signaling, and lipid metabolism has made it an essential molecule in cellular and molecular biology research. Several key applications include:

Investigating Membrane Dynamics and Lipid Signaling:

PA is used extensively to study cellular processes such as membrane biogenesis, vesicle trafficking, and intracellular signaling. Researchers utilize PA analogs and derivatives to track its role in membrane fusion, endocytosis, and exocytosis. PA's involvement in activating pathways like mTOR and MAPK makes it a key molecule in understanding cell proliferation, apoptosis, and differentiation. These insights are crucial in cancer research, as PA signaling is often dysregulated in cancer cells, leading to abnormal growth and survival.

Exploring Lipid-Protein Interactions:

PA is also employed to investigate lipid-protein interactions. By incorporating PA into lipid bilayers or using it as a signaling molecule, scientists can study how specific proteins bind to PA and mediate downstream effects. These interactions are vital for understanding the regulation of cellular processes such as signal transduction and protein trafficking.

Modeling Phospholipid Synthesis Pathways:

The biosynthesis of phospholipids, such as phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine, from PA is a key area of research in lipid metabolism. PA is often used as a starting molecule to study the enzymes involved in lipid biosynthesis, including CDP-DAG synthase, phospholipase D, and lipin. This research helps us understand how alterations in lipid synthesis contribute to metabolic disorders, neurodegenerative diseases, and other pathologies.

2. Pharmaceutical and Medical Applications

PA’s diverse physiological roles have led to its exploration as a therapeutic target and a potential biomarker in various diseases. Its applications in the pharmaceutical industry include:

Cancer Research and Therapy:

The regulation of PA in cancer cells has garnered significant attention, particularly due to its involvement in regulating cell growth and survival. Targeting the enzymes that produce or metabolize PA, such as phospholipase D or lipin, may provide novel strategies for inhibiting tumor cell proliferation and metastasis. Moreover, PA’s role in activating the mTOR pathway, which is often hyperactive in cancer cells, makes it a potential target for cancer therapeutics aimed at modulating cell growth and metabolism.

Neurodegenerative Diseases:

Given PA’s role in maintaining cellular membrane integrity and regulating neuronal signaling, its potential as a therapeutic agent in neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease is being explored. PA’s effects on neuroinflammation, vesicle trafficking, and membrane remodeling may hold promise for developing new treatments to protect neurons from stress and degeneration.

Metabolic Disorders:

PA is involved in regulating lipid and glucose metabolism, making it a key molecule in the study of metabolic diseases such as obesity, diabetes, and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD). Research into how PA regulates insulin sensitivity, adipogenesis, and lipid storage may lead to new therapeutic approaches for managing these conditions.

3. Biotechnology and Industrial Applications

PA’s biological properties have also been harnessed in industrial applications, especially in biotechnology and materials science. Some notable applications include:

Lipid Nanoparticles and Drug Delivery Systems:

PA, along with other phospholipids, is used in the formulation of lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) for drug delivery. These nanoparticles are crucial for the encapsulation and delivery of hydrophobic drugs, RNA, or gene-editing molecules like CRISPR/Cas9. The use of PA in LNPs helps enhance the stability, bioavailability, and cellular uptake of therapeutic agents, making it a cornerstone in the development of novel delivery systems for vaccines, gene therapies, and chemotherapy.

Liposome-Based Drug Delivery:

PA is often incorporated into liposomes, small spherical vesicles that can encapsulate both hydrophobic and hydrophilic drugs. Liposome-based drug delivery systems are widely used in pharmaceutical applications to enhance the solubility and targeted delivery of drugs. PA helps stabilize the lipid bilayer of liposomes, improving their efficacy in delivering therapeutics to specific tissues or organs.

Membrane Technologies and Biosensors:

In industrial biotechnology, PA is utilized in the development of artificial membranes and biosensors. Its ability to modulate membrane properties and its involvement in ion transport and signaling make it valuable in constructing bio-inspired materials, including sensors and bioelectronic devices. These materials are used in applications ranging from environmental monitoring to food safety testing and medical diagnostics.

4. Agricultural and Food Industry Applications

PA’s role in lipid metabolism and cellular stress responses also extends to agricultural applications, particularly in crop protection and food technology.

Crop Protection and Stress Resistance:

In plant biology, PA plays a key role in regulating plant responses to environmental stress, including drought, salinity, and pathogen attacks. By manipulating PA signaling pathways, researchers aim to enhance the resilience of crops, helping plants adapt to changing climates and improve agricultural yields. Additionally, PA’s involvement in lipid signaling in plants may provide new avenues for developing stress-resistant crops.

Food Emulsification and Processing:

PA and other phospholipids are used as emulsifiers in the food industry. These molecules are key in stabilizing food products like margarine, dressings, and beverages. PA’s ability to influence the fluidity and structure of lipid bilayers is leveraged to create stable emulsions, improving texture and mouthfeel in food products.

5. Cosmetic Industry Applications

The cosmetic industry has also recognized the importance of PA in maintaining skin health. PA’s ability to regulate cell membrane dynamics and lipid homeostasis makes it a beneficial ingredient in skincare formulations.

Anti-Aging and Skin Regeneration:

PA is used in cosmetic formulations aimed at rejuvenating skin and promoting cell regeneration. Its role in membrane repair and lipid homeostasis helps maintain skin barrier integrity and enhances the absorption of nutrients and active ingredients. Products containing PA are often marketed as anti-aging, promoting youthful and healthy skin by improving cellular function and reducing inflammation.

Moisturization and Lipid Balance:

PA’s ability to regulate lipid composition in cellular membranes is crucial for maintaining skin hydration and preventing water loss. In skincare products, PA helps restore the natural lipid barrier of the skin, offering benefits for dry and sensitive skin conditions.

 

Phosphatidic Acid Analysis Methods

The accurate analysis of phosphatidic acid (PA) is crucial for understanding its role in lipid metabolism, cellular signaling, and disease mechanisms. Several analytical techniques are available for quantifying PA, each offering specific advantages depending on the complexity of the sample and the research objectives. Below are the primary methods used for PA analysis:

1. Mass Spectrometry (MS)

Mass spectrometry is one of the most powerful and widely used techniques for analyzing PA due to its sensitivity, precision, and ability to detect low-abundance lipids in complex biological samples.

Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (LC-MS/MS):

LC-MS/MS combines liquid chromatography with mass spectrometry to separate and identify individual lipid species, including PA. This method is highly effective for both targeted and untargeted lipidomics, allowing the identification and quantification of PA and its molecular species in a variety of sample types such as tissues, cells, or plasma. Using specific ionization techniques, such as electrospray ionization (ESI), the MS provides detailed information about the molecular weight and fragmentation patterns of PA, enabling precise quantification.

Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization Mass Spectrometry (MALDI-MS):

MALDI-MS is another mass spectrometry technique used for the analysis of lipids like PA. This technique is particularly useful for high-throughput lipidomics, allowing the analysis of complex lipid mixtures. MALDI is commonly used in combination with imaging techniques to visualize the spatial distribution of PA within tissues and cells.

2. Thin-Layer Chromatography (TLC)

Thin-layer chromatography (TLC) is a classical, yet still widely used method for the qualitative analysis of PA. In this technique, lipids are separated on a silica gel plate based on their polarity and hydrophobicity. PA can be separated from other lipids using appropriate solvent systems, and subsequent visualization with iodine vapor or phosphomolybdic acid staining allows for the identification of PA spots. This technique is relatively simple, cost-effective, and suitable for routine lipid analysis in research settings. However, it lacks the resolution and sensitivity of modern mass spectrometry methods.

3. High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)

HPLC is another widely used technique for PA analysis, providing high resolution and sensitivity for the quantification of lipids. This method is commonly used to separate phospholipids, including PA, based on differences in hydrophobicity. It is often coupled with UV detection or mass spectrometry to improve the sensitivity and specificity of PA detection. HPLC offers reliable and reproducible results, especially for routine lipid profiling. HPLC can also be paired with enzymes, such as phospholipase D, which hydrolyze PA to produce other lipid species like DAG, helping to confirm the presence of PA in complex lipid mixtures.

4. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Spectroscopy

NMR spectroscopy is a powerful method for obtaining detailed structural information about lipids, including PA. Phosphorus-31 NMR (31P-NMR) is particularly useful for detecting phosphorus-containing lipids, including PA. By measuring the chemical shifts of phosphorus atoms in PA, NMR provides information on its molecular environment, helping researchers understand the conformation and interactions of PA within lipid membranes. Proton NMR (1H-NMR) can be used to analyze the fatty acid chains attached to the glycerol backbone of PA, providing additional structural insights.

5. Enzymatic Assays

Enzymatic methods involve the use of specific enzymes to quantify PA in biological samples. These assays rely on PA's ability to interact with phospholipase enzymes that either hydrolyze PA or generate detectable products.

Phospholipase D Assay: Phospholipase D (PLD) hydrolyzes PA into diacylglycerol (DAG) and phosphate. By measuring the amount of DAG produced, researchers can quantify PA levels in the sample. This method is simple, rapid, and cost-effective but may require specific enzyme preparations to ensure accurate results.

Colorimetric Assays: Some colorimetric assays can measure PA levels by detecting the phosphate group released during PA hydrolysis by phospholipase enzymes. These assays are often used in high-throughput settings where a large number of samples need to be analyzed.

 

Phosphatidic Acid Lipidomics Workflow

Lipidomics is the systematic study of lipids in biological systems, and the analysis of phosphatidic acid (PA) is a critical component of this field. Lipidomics workflows are designed to ensure the efficient and accurate identification, quantification, and characterization of lipid species, including PA, in complex biological samples. The following steps outline the typical workflow for analyzing phosphatidic acid using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS).

Experimental workflow of lipid analysis using MRM (Sorgi et al., 2018)

Experimental workflow of lipid analysis using MRM (Sorgi et al., 2018)

1. Sample Preparation

The first and most crucial step in any lipidomics study is the preparation of biological samples. Proper sample handling is essential to preserve lipid integrity and minimize contamination. Biological samples can include tissues, cells, plasma, serum, or other bodily fluids. The type of sample will determine the specific collection method, but it’s important to collect samples quickly and freeze them to prevent lipid degradation or oxidation. Common methods for lipid sample collection include snap-freezing in liquid nitrogen or storing samples at -80°C until analysis.

2. Lipid Extraction

Lipid extraction is a critical step in lipidomics as it isolates lipids from the biological matrix, which is typically rich in proteins and other macromolecules. There are several lipid extraction methods, but the Bligh and Dyer method is most commonly used for comprehensive lipid extraction. This method uses a chloroform-methanol-water extraction system to separate lipids from other cellular components. Lipids dissolve in the organic solvent (chloroform), while proteins and other polar compounds remain in the aqueous phase. After phase separation, the lipids are recovered and dried under a nitrogen stream for reconstitution in a suitable solvent for analysis. Solid-phase extraction (SPE) can also be used to further purify lipids, including PA. SPE cartridges can selectively capture different classes of lipids, allowing for enrichment of phospholipids like PA, which is often isolated using a specific column designed for polar lipids.

3. LC-MS/MS Analysis

Once lipids have been extracted, the next step in the workflow is to analyze the lipid profiles using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). This step is crucial for the identification, quantification, and structural analysis of PA.

The lipid extract is first injected into the LC system, where it is separated based on the polarity and hydrophobicity of the lipids. The stationary phase in the column separates PA from other lipids, allowing for its isolation before detection. Different mobile phase solvents, typically composed of water and organic solvents (e.g., methanol or acetonitrile), are used to elute the lipids in a controlled manner.

After separation by chromatography, the lipids are introduced into the mass spectrometer. Phosphatidic acid can be detected using electrospray ionization (ESI), which produces charged ions from lipids for detection. Positive ionization is typically used for phospholipids like PA, with the m/z (mass-to-charge ratio) values corresponding to the molecular ions of PA species.

MS/MS analysis involves fragmenting the lipid ions generated in the first stage of MS to produce daughter ions. This fragmentation pattern can be used to confirm the identity of PA species and determine the structure of fatty acid chains, the position of the phosphate group, and other molecular features. The combination of high-resolution mass spectrometry with tandem MS provides highly accurate and detailed lipid profiles.

4. Data Analysis

Once the data has been acquired from the LC-MS/MS analysis, the next step is to analyze the raw data to identify and quantify phosphatidic acid species in the sample. This step involves peak detection, integration, and assignment of lipid species based on their molecular weights and fragmentation patterns. Using specialized software, the chromatographic peaks corresponding to PA and its molecular species are identified. The peak areas are integrated to quantify PA levels in the sample. The area under the curve of each peak is proportional to the amount of PA present.

The data generated by LC-MS/MS is then processed using lipid-specific databases and libraries (e.g., LIPID MAPS, LipidBlast) to match the observed mass spectra with known PA species. This step helps to assign lipid species based on their m/z values, fatty acid chains, and other structural characteristics. Quantification is typically achieved using internal standards or external calibration curves. Internal standards are added to the lipid extract before extraction to correct for sample loss and variation. The abundance of PA species is measured in relative or absolute terms based on the intensity of their peaks in the mass spectrometer.

5. Bioinformatic Analysis

After the identification and quantification of PA species, bioinformatic tools and approaches are used to extract meaningful biological information from the data. This involves data normalization, statistical analysis, and pathway analysis to interpret the results within the context of lipid metabolism, disease mechanisms, or experimental conditions.

The raw data is normalized to account for variations in sample preparation, extraction, and analysis. This helps to ensure that the differences in lipid profiles reflect biological differences rather than technical artifacts. Quality control checks are performed to assess the reproducibility and reliability of the data.

Multivariate statistical techniques, such as principal component analysis (PCA) or partial least squares discriminant analysis (PLS-DA), are applied to explore the relationships between PA levels and experimental variables (e.g., disease state, treatment conditions). These analyses help identify patterns and trends in the lipid data and can be used to classify samples or identify biomarkers.

Lipidomics data, including PA species, is often integrated with other omics data (e.g., transcriptomics, proteomics) to provide insights into lipid signaling and metabolic pathways. Bioinformatic tools like Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA) or MetaboAnalyst can help map PA metabolism to biological pathways, providing a deeper understanding of its role in cellular processes, stress responses, and diseases.

 

Zhou, H., Huo, Y., Yang, N., & Wei, T. (2024). Phosphatidic acid: from biophysical properties to diverse functions. The FEBS journal, 291(9), 1870–1885. https://doi.org/10.1111/febs.16809

Sorgi, C. A., Peti, A. P. F., Petta, T., Meirelles, A. F. G., Fontanari, C., Moraes, L. A. B., & Faccioli, L. H. (2018). Comprehensive high-resolution multiple-reaction monitoring mass spectrometry for targeted eicosanoid assays. Scientific data, 5, 180167. https://doi.org/10.1038/sdata.2018.167

 

Read more:

· Lipid Profiles Collection

· Metabolomics Biomarker Research Series

· Metabolomics Technology Introduction Collection

· Omics Data Processing Series

· Omics Data Analysis Series

· Multi-Omics Association Analysis Series

Contact Us
Name can't be empty
Email error!
Message can't be empty
CONTACT FOR DEMO

WHAT'S NEXT IN OMICS: THE METABOLOME

Please submit a detailed description of your project. We will provide you with a customized project plan metabolomics services to meet your research requests. You can also send emails directly to support-global@metwarebio.com for inquiries.
Name can't be empty
Email error!
Message can't be empty
CONTACT FOR DEMO
+1(781)975-1541
LET'S STAY IN TOUCH
submit
Copyright © Metware Biotechnology Inc. All Rights Reserved.
support-global@metwarebio.com +1(781)975-1541
8A Henshaw Street, Woburn, MA 01801
Contact Us Now
Name can't be empty
Email error!
Message can't be empty